AI, Tools & Technology and Research Integrity, Concerns and Appeals
1. Principles
We investigate every concern about the misuse of AI or other technology fairly and in proportion to its seriousness. We follow the guidance and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Everyone involved has the chance to respond. No one is sanctioned on the basis of an AI-detector score alone.
2. Matters we investigate
AI use that should have been disclosed but was not.
Fabricated, falsified or manipulated data, images or figures.
References that do not exist or do not support the claims made.
AI-generated text, ideas or images presented as the authors' original work.
Attempts to manipulate peer review, including hidden prompts aimed at AI tools.
Manuscripts or reviews entered into public AI tools by reviewers or editors.
Paper-mill activity, including the mass production of AI-generated manuscripts or reviews.
3. Procedure
Assessment: the handling editor reviews the concern and records the evidence.
Response: we inform the people concerned and invite their explanation. We may ask for drafts, prompts, original images or raw data.
Expert review: serious or complex cases are referred to the Research Integrity and Publication Ethics Office.
Institutional involvement: where necessary, the author's institution is asked to investigate.
Decision: we reach a proportionate outcome and explain it in writing.
Cases remain confidential while they are being investigated.
4. Possible outcomes
Disclosure honestly omitted and research sound: the AI Use Statement is added before publication, or a correction is published afterwards.
Concerns unresolved after publication: an expression of concern is published while the investigation continues.
Fabrication, manipulation, plagiarism or paper-mill activity: the manuscript is rejected or the article is retracted. The institution and, where relevant, the funder may be informed.
Breach by a reviewer or editor: the review is set aside, and the person may be removed from reviewer or editorial roles.
Serious or repeated misconduct: a temporary or permanent ban from submitting, reviewing or editing at all our journals.
5. Voluntary correction
Authors who realize they did not disclose AI use should contact the editor promptly. If the research is sound, the usual outcome is an added AI Use Statement or a correction.
6. Reporting a concern
Anyone, including readers, may report a concern about an article, a review or an editorial process. Email [integrity email address] with:
the article title, DOI or manuscript number;
a clear description of the concern;
any supporting evidence.
We acknowledge every report. If you ask, we keep your identity confidential.
7. Appeals
Decisions made under this policy may be appealed within 30 days. Send your reasons and any new evidence to [appeals email address]. An editor or officer who was not involved in the original decision will review the appeal and reply in writing. If the matter is still unresolved, you may contact COPE through its complaints procedure.




